Partnerships for Innovation Workshop
March 30 - April 1, 2008


Workshop 1: Sustaining Innovation

Moderators:
Session a:
Raj Veeramani and Brad Kramer

Session b: Russ Lea and Linbing Wang

Each PFI project has at a minimum a partnership that involves a private sector partner. It has been up to the discretion of the project teams to choose a set of partners best suited to achieve the goals of their respective projects. Partnerships come in many different sizes and shapes and may include educational institutions; Federal, state and local government agencies or offices; and businesses, large and small; and nonprofit organizations. Such partnerships are nuclei of innovation that connect new scientific discoveries to practical uses within the communities. This session will focus on how best to sustain current partnerships, establish new collaborations, and continue on the innovation pathway. The PFI community will share ideas, experiences and best practices, and discuss strategies to sustain innovation after the PFI grant has ended.

1. Success stories of PFI projects that have obtained succeeding funding from other programs of NSF or other agencies, private sectors or resulted in patents, copyrights, industrial standards, and royalties. How to achieve these successes?

2. Has the PFI project actually altered the campus culture for promoting innovation and commercialization? If not, how to improve it?

3. Highly-risky and creative research may not be matured enough within the PFI time and budget frame for direct commercialization. How to solve this problem? Can we have potential second round funding for those projects that need additional developments to achieve maturity (with requirements that industrial cash support is committed)?

4. Did the PFI project alter the resources that are committed to the Tech Transfer office to enable rapid development of technologies (licensing) or launch companies (spin out or spin in) with SBIR or Angel fund assistance? Is there possibility for SBIR to pick up some PFI ideas for further development or implementation?

5. How to increase and measure the success of the PFI education components? How to evaluate the long-term impacts resulted from the education components?

6. Are there success stories on international outreach? Is there any potential international opportunity perceived ?

7. What campus derived incentives and recognition are provided that don't impede faculty entrepreneurs?

8. Can faculty maintain part-time appointments in their campus units while serving as officers in private ventures?

9. Are the campus COI/COC policies elastic enough to ensure faculty can follow their innovations to the marketplace?

10. Specifically what can the PFI community do to achieve sustainability?

11. My grant is coming to an end, how can I continue to do the good work once the NSF funding runs out?

12. How do I go about getting university buy-in to institutionalize the
innovation efforts that my team has developed?

13. The ideal innovation partner, how do I identify, recruit, and retain
industrial collaborators?

14. Industrial sponsors are from Mars, University researchers are from
Venus - how do I get the two to speak the same language and identify
common objectives?

15. What are the pitfalls and traps that should be avoided to make sure> that my innovation project will succeed?